跳转到内容
Blackroom 现已开启 — 黑色星期五优惠来了。优惠来了
BikeroomBikeroom
选择您的语言
选择您的位置
中美洲
亚洲
北美洲
南美洲
大洋洲
欧洲
非洲
0
Aero or Climbing Bike: Does the Difference Still Matter?

Aero or Climbing Bike: Does the Difference Still Matter?

Summary

  • In TOUR's wind tunnel at 45 km/h, the top Scott Foil RC build needs 203 W against 214 W for the top Addict RC build, which TOUR weighed at 5.98 kg.
  • TOUR measured Colnago's Y1Rs at 204 W and 7.4 kg; Colnago claims the V5Rs is 9 W faster than the V4Rs, and TOUR reports its lightest build about 600 g under the Y1Rs.
  • Bianchi claims a 250 W rider is faster on the Specialissima RC than the Oltre RC from gradients of 4.2%.
  • Ridley says its new Falcn RS 2.0 is around 10 W slower than the Noah Fast at 50 km/h, with a claimed 705 g frame.

Most race brands still split the top of their range in two. One frame is drawn for the wind, the other for the climbs. A few years ago that split meant a heavy aero bike and a light, round-tubed climber. Today both have moved towards the middle, and the honest question is whether the difference is still worth choosing for.

Why the gap is smaller than it was

Two things squeezed it. The first is the UCI's 6.8 kg minimum weight, which caps how light a race bike can be in competition. Below that line, a lighter frame brings no advantage in a UCI race, so the gap on race day can be smaller than the catalogue suggests. Our piece on the UCI 6.8 kg weight limit covers how it works.

The second is that climbing bikes have borrowed aero shaping. Truncated tube profiles, hidden cables and deeper wheels now appear on frames sold as lightweight. TOUR saw the direction early. In a 2018 test of 20 bikes it concluded: "The aero model is the faster bike in almost all cases."

Five pairs, with the numbers that exist

Brand Aero bike Climbing bike What the data says Source
Scott Foil RC Addict RC 203 W vs 214 W at 45 km/h; Foil about 1 kg heavier TOUR, measured
Colnago Y1Rs V5Rs Y1Rs 204 W, 7.4 kg; V5Rs claimed 9 W faster than V4Rs (221 W) TOUR measured; Colnago claim
Bianchi Oltre RC Specialissima RC Specialissima claimed faster from 4.2% at 250 W Bianchi claim via BikeRadar
Ridley Noah Fast Falcn RS 2.0 Falcn RS claimed about 10 W slower at 50 km/h Ridley claim via BikeRadar
Wilier Filante SLR 0 SLR Frames claimed at 870 g and 780 g; no aero figure for the 0 SLR Wilier claims via BikeRadar and road.cc

Scott Foil RC and Addict RC

This is the cleanest comparison because TOUR measured both. The top Foil RC build needed 203 W to overcome its own drag at 45 km/h in TOUR's 2026 aero ranking. The top Addict RC build needed 214 W, which TOUR called the best figure it had recorded for a lightweight bike. TOUR weighed the Addict at 5.98 kg and put the Foil and Canyon Aeroad around 1,000 grams heavier.

Eleven watts at 45 km/h, against one kilogram. Our Scott Foil 2027 article covers the new Foil in detail.

Colnago Y1Rs and V5Rs

TOUR measured the Y1Rs at 204 W at 45 km/h and 7.4 kg in size M. The previous climbing bike, the V4Rs, needed 221 W in the same tunnel. Colnago claims the V5Rs is 9 W faster than the V4Rs at 50 km/h, from its own mannequin testing across yaw angles. TOUR reports that the lightest V5Rs build should save around 600 grams over the Y1Rs.

No independent figure for the V5Rs was published at the time of writing, so the real gap between the two current Colnagos is not yet measured.

Bianchi Oltre RC and Specialissima RC

Bianchi is the only brand in this list to publish a crossover point. In BikeRadar's 2024 review, Bianchi claims the Specialissima RC beats the Oltre RC from 6% gradients at 420 W, from 4.9% at 300 W, and from 4.2% at 250 W. BikeRadar weighed its 55 cm test bike at 6.75 kg.

The useful reading is the direction, not the decimals. The lower your power, the gentler the slope at which weight starts to matter more than drag.

Ridley Noah Fast and Falcn RS 2.0

The Noah Fast 3.0 measured 202 W in TOUR's 2026 aero ranking. Ridley launched the Falcn RS 2.0 in October 2026 and, according to BikeRadar, claims it is around 10 W slower than the Noah Fast at 50 km/h. The trade is a claimed 705 g frame in size M and builds from a claimed 6.2 kg.

Wilier Filante SLR and 0 SLR

Wilier claims 870 g for the Filante SLR frame, as reported by BikeRadar, and 780 g plus or minus 5% for a medium 0 SLR frame, as reported by road.cc. That is about 90 g between the brand's aero and climbing frames. Wilier has not published a comparable drag figure for the 0 SLR, and has since introduced the Verticale SLR as its climbing frame.

What those watts mean at your speed

Wind tunnel figures at 45 km/h describe a fast group ride or a race. Power lost to drag rises with the cube of speed. The 11 W between the two Scotts at 45 km/h works out at roughly 3 W at 30 km/h, by that rule alone.

Weight works the other way. On a steep climb, almost all your power goes into lifting rider plus bike. For a 75 kg rider on a 7 kg bike, an extra 600 g is under 1% of the total mass.

Neither number is large. That is the real answer to the headline: for most riders, fit, tyres and position matter more than the frame category.

How to choose

  • If you ride fast on flat or rolling roads, or race criteriums and road races, the aero frame is the stronger choice, and the weight penalty is now modest.
  • If your riding is mostly long climbs at moderate power, the climbing frame earns its place, especially below the 250 W range where Bianchi's crossover drops near 4%.
  • If you want one bike for everything, look at the current climbing frames with aero shaping, or the lighter aero frames, rather than the extremes of either category.

Ride feel matters as well. Aero frames often carry deeper tubes and integrated cockpits that limit adjustment, while climbing frames tend to feel livelier when you stand up. Our guide to aero, endurance and superlight bikes covers the categories in general terms.

Where to look

The pairs above all appear on the pre-owned market, where a previous generation narrows the price gap between the two categories. Start with the Scott Foil RC and Scott Addict RC, or the Colnago Y1Rs alongside the V5Rs. The full road bike range covers the other brands in this piece.

If you are torn between an aero frame and a climbing frame for the roads you actually ride, talk to our concierge with your usual routes and power in mind.

Sources: TOUR, The 12 fastest road bikes in the world, 4 August 2026; TOUR, Scott Addict RC on test, 9 November 2025; TOUR, Colnago Y1Rs on test, 20 July 2025; TOUR, Colnago presents new V5Rs, 16 April 2025; TOUR, Aero versus lightweight construction, 12 January 2018; BikeRadar, Bianchi Specialissima RC review, 17 February 2024; BikeRadar, Ridley Falcn RS 2.0, October 2026; BikeRadar, Wilier Filante SLR, 10 November 2020; road.cc, Astana's Wilier Zero SLR, 11 September 2020; Wilier, Verticale SLR.